Bizarre fish caught by angler

cbd35b91-519a-4638-aa13-bbd127e65cfb

Editor's Picks
Features Post
What caused this snail die-off?
04 January 2022
Fishkeeping News Post
Nanochromis transvestitus
04 January 2022
Features Post
How do I feed these tricky gobies?
04 January 2022
Features Post
Should I add sand for my Rams?
04 January 2022
Features Post
How to set up your Christmas tank
20 December 2021


At first glance this looks like a goldfish — but is it?

Angler Mark Sawyer made the freak catch while fishing at Magpie Lake, Cambridge.

Mark, who is the Tackle Editor on Angling Times magazine, said then when he caught the fish, he thought at first it was just a common brown-coloured goldfish, but on closer inspection it appeared to be made up of at least three species, with the head of a Roach, the body of a Common goldfish, the tail fin of a Fantail and the anal fin of a Bream.

He said: "I have shown the picture to a number of marine boffins who say it is definitely the result of mixed parentage.

"I have caught thousands and thousands of fish but have never seen anything like it before. It is a proper oddity."

One expert said the fish was truly a one-off and he hadn't seen anything like it in the UK before. He said it seemed likely that a Fantail goldfish had been released into the lake at some stage, either from an aquarium or pond, where it had since bred with a Common carp. The fish that Mark caught would have been one of the offspring.

However, another expert said he thought the fish was the result of a Fantail goldfish breeding with a Common goldfish and that it had probably been released by a fishkeeper.

The unusual catch, which has been dubbed 'Frankenstein fish' by the press, was returned to the lake after the photos were taken.

What do you think the fish is? We'd be interested in your views.

Why not take out a subscription to Practical Fishkeeping magazine? See our latest subscription offer.