In an extraordinary video capture, a fish collector in Hawaii has been filmed attacking Rene Umberger, a photographer for the Sea Shepherd conservation society, writes Nathan Hill.
The attack, which could have easily proven fatal, has renewed discussion and rhetoric between anti-industry conservationists and those who are pro-hobby, pro-trade and pro-collection of wild marine livestock (scroll down for video).
Unfortunately, this discussion is now running the risk of derailing as people become increasingly heated in their sentiments. More time seems to be spent bandying emotions than reason, and this needs to stop. I want to suggest we bring things back into a moderate position again — assuming that an attempt on someone’s life can ever be dealt with moderately. Mud flinging has been rife, and quite shamefully neither side has behaved impeccably.
There has been contention between the aquarium industry and Sea Shepherd for some time. This is pretty much unavoidable, as Sea Shepherd holds the position that collection of wild fish is unsustainable and should be halted with immediate effect. That’s not exactly conducive to a thriving aquarium industry.
By coincidence, it was just this week that Sea Shepherd launched 'Operation Reef Defence' in Hawaii. The aim of this, as Sea Shepherd point out on their website is to "end the destruction of coral reefs and the many threats they are facing worldwide." Well, I don’t think anyone can really argue with that particular, noble goal.
Sea Shepherd go on to point out in their mission statement that: "30 percent of the world’s coral reef population has died in the last 50 years. Another 30 percent has suffered severe damage, and 60 percent could die in less than 25 years because of human-induced activities such as pollution, overfishing, reef wildlife trafficking, coastal development and global warming."
This raises some questions, and seems a tad myopic. In Sea Shepherd’s defence, if these claims are all true, and can all be heaped at the door of aquarists, then we have an awful lot to answer for. The problem for Sea Shepherd, however, is demonstrating exactly how these figures were attained, and exactly how hobbyists and the aquarium trade are responsible.
And heaping these woes on aquarists’ doors, Sea Shepherd are quite explicit about. They make the very clear statement that: "Massive reef wildlife dies every year as disposable ornamentation in the vicious cycle of wildlife trafficking for the pet trade."
Note the use of emotive words here, and the very specific begging of the question — that is to say assuming one of the very points under contention. The word that jumps out at me straight away is 'trafficking'. In the sense used here, to 'traffic' means quite specifically to trade or deal in something that is illegal.
Welcome to the first stumbling block. Hobbyists aren’t interested in trafficking fish. We want no truck with an illegal collection racket for livestock. In that, I think we would all get behind Sea Shepherd and say that we want the illegitimate, unregulated and illegal harvesting of livestock for any purpose to stop. But we’d politely ask that we don’t get tarred with the same brush. That’s a serious allegation.
That said, if there is substance to this allegation, then I want to know more. If there’s an illegal element feeding the trade, operating out of sight and with impunity, then I’ll happily join Sea Shepherd in exposing it. But I’m confident that the mainstay of our trade is all above board. I’m somewhat affronted by this unqualified label that tries to assert that responsible aquarists are somehow implicit in illegal trading.
Sea Shepherd go on to say that: "Death generates continuing demand, driving the aquarium trade to strip reefs bare. 25 million creatures are in the commercial aquarium pipeline at any given moment. Nearly all will die within a year from the point of capture." Woah there, Sea Shepherd. Death causes people to leave the hobby, eventually killing it. Nobody wants ornamental fish to die (to my knowledge), as this makes no commercial sense at all. I also notice the subtle moving of the goalposts here, tangling 'trafficking' from before, with 'aquarium trade' now. The two are not synonymous, and I openly accuse Sea Shepherd of attempting the most egregious casuistry.
Even despite this tacky wordplay, the figures don’t appear to be on Sea Shepherd’s side anyway. Robert Wintner, Sea Shepherd’s Vice-president and something of a walking hashtag for the society, has been repeatedly asked to cite reference to the figures he bandies so damningly. To my knowledge, so far, none have been forthcoming.
This is more than I can hope to cover here, and I confess to being absent of some of the contacts I’d need to pursue it (as Sea Shepherd seems primarily geared against the American market instead of the UK one). I’m aware that American journalist Ret Talbot has written quite comprehensively on the subject of Sea Shepherd and Robert Wintner, and I recommend a look at his blog on the subject for a wider overview.
But none of this warrants an attack on a diver. What has been damning from our side of the fence is that some folks have — perhaps in the heat of the moment — made the vilest remarks. "Next time, pull of the mask AND the regulator…" was one such sentiment I came across, and there are many more like it.
Well, shame on us if that’s the position we’re going to take. I don’t care how opposed to someone’s opinion you are, or how much offence you might take from their actions, to wish them harm is abhorrent. We as a collective industry should be above this, as I know the majority of us are.
It remains that if we’re not prepared to listen to the arguments against our position, we become a dead dogma. Even if the whole world were in agreement about the current state of the aquarium trade, with just one, single dissident, then it is just as vital that we hear that noncomformist voice out.
I’m sure there is much more to the story of the attacked diver than is being let on, but all we can do is speculate. Perhaps there was a campaign of relentless harassment against this one antagonised diver until his or her resolve snapped. Though if I’m going to propose that, I should at least posit an alternative suggestion: perhaps those were illegal fishermen of the exact kind Sea Shepherd highlights. Perhaps this was trafficking of fish, plain and simple. We do not know. But to wish harm to the victim on the basis of her views is repugnant, and I’d like to think that anyone reading this will join me in wishing Rene Umberger a speedy recovery from any shock endured from the assault.
I also invite both sides of this debate to engage in sensible discussion without the need for hostility. But as a closing remark, I would have to state that I have tried to contact Sea Shepherd on several occasions now, and have not once been graced with a response. I’ll let you make of that what you will, because I’m more than comfortable arguing for my side of the pro-trade position with any of their representatives.
A fishkeeper from Turkey has become so obsessed with the hobby that he has moved his fish from the family home in Ankara and into a separate flat to save his marriage.
A new species of lanternshark has been described from the central eastern Pacific Ocean.
Results of a new study contradict some of the views on the fish family tree...
An aquatics dealer from the West Midlands has pleaded guilty to three charges of smuggling endangered corals.
Hold on to any money you might be given for Christmas if you're a fan of fancy goldfish, as Surrey-based specialist Star Fisheries is holding an Open Cay on January 17, 2016, with a whole host of tempting fish on offer!
A new company that was receiving a lot of attention from visitors to the recent AQUA trade show in Telford was KoralSea.
A Cownose ray pup is doing swimmingly after being born by caesarian section at an aquarium in the US - and it's thought to be a first!
A fire that broke out in the kitchen area of a U.S. aquarium was attended to by the fire brigade, while Santa and Mrs Claus helped to evacuate guests and staff.
Though happy to make off with cash and electrical goods, robbers took the time to rescue a goldfish harmed during their break in, writes Nathan Hill
In a sudden show of unexpected conscience, burglers in Wollaton, Nottinghamshire have rescued a goldfish.
When home owners Lance and Monica McGill returned to their property, they feared the worst after finding their possessions gone and their goldfish bowl smashed. However, further investigation revealed that the intruders had taken the time to place Freddie the goldfish into a sink with some water, where his owners found him swimming.
It's thought that the bowl was knocked to the floor while the thieves were searching for valuables, and cash, a camera and laptops were stolen during the burglary.
'We phoned the police straight away and they said not to touch anything until they got there, so we just waited,' Monica McGill said.
'It wasn't until they had left two hours later that I went to the kitchen sink for a drink and saw Freddie looking up at me.
'He was just there splashing around in the sink without a care in the world. You wouldn't have known what he had just been through. He looked quite content.
'I couldn't believe they went out of their way to save him. I thought he was gone for sure.
'It is mixed feelings really. They are still thieves that need catching - but we are really grateful they took the time to save Freddie.
'We bought him for my youngest daughter from a garden centre for her first birthday so she is quite fond of him. She was really happy when we found out he was alive.
‘The more I think about it, the more it makes sense. They’re just there to take whatever they can to make some money from.
TMC has extended its range of aquarium lighting, offering this much simpler and more affordable upgrade to LEDs for those fishkeepers still using T5 and T8 tubes, including those with Juwel and Eheim set-ups.
We reveal your favourite shops, manufacturers and products of 2015, as voted for by readers of Practical Fishkeeping in this year's poll.
Turtles in Japan have been given their own special passageways under railway tracks to prevent them being crushed,
A Russian make-up artist has come under fire after she posted photos on her Instagram pages showing models wearing dead fish on their faces, which had been killed specially for the shoot.
The fish included Tiger barbs, angelfish and Neon tetras stuck to the models' faces alongside other decor, for a mermaid-themed shoot.
The images that Elya Bulochka then shared among her 25,000 followers caused a backlash with animal lovers calling her 'stupid' and saying that the fish had been killed unnecessarily.
One of her followers said: "'This is not art, just another stupid person killing animals for nothing." Another said: "Today one dead fish, tomorrow someone's finger. Disgusted that all this is referred to as the art of makeup."
You can find a link to one of several photos from the shoot below.
Why not take out a subscription to Practical Fishkeeping magazine? See our latest subscription offer.
Don't forget PFK is also available in digital format.
Not only do cuttlefish employ visual camouflage when a predator looms nearby, but new research shows they also manage to cloak their electrical fields.
The latest Catfish Study Group auction was held on Sunday, November 15 in Darwen, Lancashire.
A new study by scientists in Japan has found that Daffodil cichlids, Neolamprologus pulcher, can recognise individual fish by looking at their facial features.
A UK company has launched what it says is the worldâ€™s first universal fitting, four-tube, replacement T5 lighting unit: the iQuatics Aqualumi Universal T5 Lighting Bar.
A new study has found that fish may experience â€˜emotional feverâ€™, which has been used as a basis for proving sentience or consciousness in other species. Until now many experts have seen fish as not being sentient beings in the same way as mammals and birds.
This is an exciting opportunity to help manage and influence the future development of one the worldâ€™s largest water gardening brands. Interested? Read on...
- Experience of the water gardening market, in either a trade or retail capacity, would be a major advantage in this role.
- Excellent project management skills are a must, as you’ll be co-ordinating global projects involving multiple offices/suppliers.
- You may or may not be a graduate, but a good knowledge and capacity for marketing and a business or marketing related qualification would be advantageous.
- Most important is a hands on and ‘can do’ attitude to further the success of this well established brand in a competitive and technical marketplace.
- You must have a full UK driving license.
- Initiating and co-ordinating European and global product development programmes.
- Conducting research activities with retailers and consumers to identify future development opportunities.
- Developing packaging layouts for new products.
- Updating and promoting our website www.lagunaponds.com, Facebook and Twitter feeds.
- Creating in-store promotional materials, trade and consumer literature and advertising campaigns.
- Supporting our sales team by creating and delivering key customer presentations and product Co-ordinating global brand activity and communication.
Why not take out a subscription to Practical Fishkeeping magazine? See our latest subscription offer.